Lawyers familiar with cases of conversion say the Negri Sembilan
Islamic Affairs Department (JHEAINS) cannot cite the family of the late Lawrence
Selvanathan for contempt of the syariah court for cremating his remains. According to noted syariah lawyer Muhamad
Burok, this is because the family is Christian and they therefore do not fall
under the jurisdiction of the syariah court.
"The jurisdiction of the syariah court, according to the
Administration of the Religion of Islam (Negri Sembilan) Enactment 2003, only
extends to cases where all parties are Muslim."This is the law, but if there is a clause that allows (the
contempt action) then let me know," Muhamad said when
contacted.
Agreeing with him, lawyer M
Kulasegaran said the federal constitution, through the inclusion of clause (1A)
into Article 121, clearly states that Malaysia practices two parallel legal
systems.
The clause states that the high
courts have "no jurisdiction in respect of any matter within the jurisdiction of
the syariah court".
It also states that
the syariah court has jurisdiction only "over persons professing the religion of
Islam". "In view of this, the law does
not apply to non-Muslims, subpoenas don't apply and it is my view that contempt
also does not apply," Kulasegaran said.